Greece: An employment goal could help – not only in Greece, even in Germany

Greece’s new prime minister, Alexis Tsipras, and the new finance minister, Yanis Varoufakis, travel Europe to discuss and negotiate new concepts to overcome the Euro crisis in general and that of Greece in particular. It seems still not clear where they will focus on. There is much ado about a debt haircut. But the most sustainable way to cut the burden of debt is to stimulate growth. The same with unemployment, which is actually the most urgent problem to resolve, not only in Greece, but in Spain, Portugal, France, Italy and other countries as well – even in Germany, which is miles away from full employment. Thus, an employment goal should be at the centre of the negotiations. In order to concretise such a goal it is necessary to be aware of the relationship between growth and employment.

Since the outbreak of the financial and Euro crisis 2009 economic growth in Greece has been insufficient: the real growth rate (employed persons multiplied by labour productivity per person) has fallen far below the potential growth rate (employed persons and unemployed persons multiplied by labour productivity per person) (1). Under this condition unemployment rises (see chart below).

Click to enlarge chart.

To reverse that in a decrease in unemployment it needs a necessary growth rate of real gross domestic product (GDP) that is higher than the potential growth rate. The potential growth rate in Greece before the outbreak of the crisis was around two percent in average (2001-2007: 1,99%; 2001-2008: 1,73%). On that basis the necessary real growth rate of GDP must be between three and four percent if the employment goal is to bring down the unemployment rate by two percentage points a year (see chart below) (2). Greece´s unemployment rate now is around 26 percent.

Clikc to enlarge chart.

This necessary growth rate is at the same time approximately that growth rate needed to fulfill the stability criteria of the Economic Monetary Union (EMU). Since the inflation target of the European Central Bank (ECB) is “below, but close to two percent” the nominal growth rate should be around five percent. A nominal growth rate of five percent is necessary to maintain a fiscal deficit-to-GDP ratio of three percent and a government debt-to-GDP ratio of 60 percent.

Once you have such an employment goal and the necessary growth rate to reach it you have a proper basis for thinking and negotiating the conditions to achieve such a neceassary growth rate.

Two crucial conditions should be discussed:

First, the price differences which have accumulated since the beginning of the EMU in 1999 due to different inflation rates. For example, according to own calculations, Greece would still have to “devalue” around twenty percent to reach purchasing power parity with Germany. Which obviously is not only socially unbearable but economically, too. Experience with austerity (cutting government expenses and wages to “devalue”) clearly shows its counterproductive effects on growth, employment and debt. Thus, a balance of the accumulated price levels have to be reached in a different way, also to avoid further deflation. It is a collective responsibilty. Countries which have persistently realized inflation rates below ECB´s inflation target already before the outbreak of the crisis have to adjust as well. The current account surplusses Germany still realizes even with Greece between 2011 and 2014 should be discussed in that context.

Click to enlarge chart.

Second, industries to invest should systematically be analysed. A look at the foreign trade structure of Greece shows a share of manufactured products of 54 percent in total exports before the outbreak of the crisis. Under austerity it has shrunk to 30 percent (2013). Before the crisis Greece´s share of manufactured products in world trade of manufactured products remained nearly unchanged. It steadily decreased under austerity.

Of course, this is not a comprehensive plan to overcome the Euro crisis in general and that of Greece in particular. But it seems to me a proper framework to discuss and negotiate in the right direction.

—

(1) The concept of sufficient / insufficient growth has been developed by Claus Köhler, professor in economics and a former member of the German Council of Economic Experts.

(2) 5th February, 2015: In an earlier version we made a mistake due to a wrong data transfer of our calculations in the chart. That´s also the reason why this version no longer contains the calculation of bringing down the unemployment rate by five percentage points a year, since then the necessary growth rate is around six percent which doesn´t seem realistic and which would no longer be in line with the above mentioned stability criteria.


Dieser Text ist mir etwas wert


Verwandte Artikel: