Greece: Why Greece shouldn´t pay back its government debt

If there is one thing the opponents – the word partners unfortunately seems no longer fitting – have in common it is their focus on government debt. The whole debate, the whole dispute starts and ends up in one way or another always with the debt question. There is actually no rational explanation for this. Since every debt problem is mainly about economic growth.

If there is sufficient economic growth any debt will be no burden. Its level decreases then in relation to economic activity (Gross Domestic Product, GDP). That holds true for domestic as well as for foreign debt. At the same time economic growth in Greece is not hampered by government debt or any debt, but by the attempt to decrease the debt via heavily cutting government expenses, increase taxes especially hitting the poor and low and average income earners like the value added tax and – to make the economy more competitive – cutting wages and remove employment rights. That is the core of austerity, the policy the EU-Commission, the IMF, the ECB and national governments, headed by the German government, have imposed on Greece since April 2010 (see also the analysis by Claus Köhler, former member of the German Council of Economic Experts here). And it is exactly against this background that Greece shouldn´t pay back its government debt – at least not that part increased since those austerity measures were introduced. Since that debt is the result of a policy imposed by the named institutions.

This is most clearly shown by the development since the 2011/2012 debt cut as the following chart tries to illustrate. Whereas the government debt in Million Euro (red line) stays pretty much the same after the debt cut, the government debt in relation to GDP has again very much increased and returned back to its pre-debt-cut growth path. That is the case because growth of GDP has collapsed under austerity. We have here the same relationship we can observe as we look on the development of the unemployment rate and growth of GDP on which the whole debate actually should have focused on instead of the pretended debt problem.

Click to enlarge chart.

—

You can support this journal by subscribing it and/or by a donation. Thank you.


Dieser Text ist mir etwas wert


Verwandte Artikel: