“Ireland’s worst recession since the 1970’s finally over”, “Ireland will sky-rocket if global economy improves”, “Irish economy to be Europe’s bright spot”…”Ireland and Germany take lead roles in euro zone recovery” …These are some of the happy headlines found in our newspapers over the last few weeks.
The politicians are literally shining with glee at the thought of Ireland and Germany, together, taking “lead roles” in European economic recovery.
This idea of a harmonious partnership put forward by the media is somewhat divorced from reality. Firstly, the relationship is inherently unequal and, secondly, it has come at too high a cost.
Putting this in perhaps simplistic – but practical – terms: a policy of structural adjustment has been imposed on Ireland by EU creditor states, of which Germany has emerged as the main player. Whatever the merits of the insane debtor-creditor system that seems to dominate global economics, this is hardly the basis of a healthy relationship.
This all brings me back to my study of international development as an undergraduate student. Multilateral banks like the IMF, who had lent money to African states following independence, demanded those countries cut spending in order to repay the loans: spending on vital health services, education and public amenities, and instead focus on becoming export-led economies. We learned about the consequences of these policies for most African people even though, often, an elite layer benefitted. Poverty, hunger, disease and degradation resulted and health systems were rendered too weak and inefficient to deal with crises or epidemics. (Ironically, western-funded NGOs flooded in to try to fill the gaps in service delivery.)
Most Irish people don’t see their nation as having anything in common with post-colonial African states. The comparison might raise some uncomfortable issues about our collective mindset; one that struggles with a lingering dependency that is, presumably, a remnant of colonial rule. However, look past the snappy headlines and the smiling faces of our politicians – focus instead on the empty, derelict buildings, rising inequality, struggling health systems and the way in which export-led growth is being shoved down our throat as the only possible way to recovery, and you may see the similarities. Structural Adjustment Programs were created in the 1980’s with the goal of reducing the borrowing country’s fiscal imbalances, just like austerity policies do today, and they were widely recognised as disastrous.
So, is this really a partnership? I don’t consider myself to be in partnership with Mastercard, to whom I owe money, and thankfully they don’t come to my house and insist that I cut back on my doctors visits or that I only eat canned food.
Moving on from the inherent unbalance in the relationship there is also the issue of its cost. Our government, in its mission to please, pursued austerity policies at the expense of its legitimacy in the eyes of the citizens. First, when Irish people voted against the Lisbon Treaty in a referendum we were asked to vote again, so we could get the right answer. Maybe the result was emotive, maybe it reflected frustration at the political system, or maybe people simply didn’t understand it: whatever the rights or wrongs of a ‘no’ vote, the fact is that when a population gets asked to vote twice on the same issue, it undermines the democratic process and people’s faith in it.
Secondly, during the referendum on the Fiscal Compact, the government spent public money promoting a yes vote. There were even leaked suggestions that if the result were a ‘no’ vote there could be a second referendum. Taoiseach Enda Kenny pleaded with us that ratification of the treaty was the only way, that it was essential in order to restore investor confidence (this almighty “confidence” which, apparently, can only be won when governments place corporate interests above those of the electorate). Like Lisbon, we were basically force-fed the Fiscal Compact and were left feeling disenfranchised, powerless and vaguely humiliated.
There is a two-tier system in place here: the people and the government, which is not how a democracy should work. Decisions are made over our heads and this disconnect is totally unsustainable in the long term. Yes, some people are happy about the alleged growth forecasts, but the chain of causality between growth and actual benefits for people on the ground is not always straightforward, even less so if the link between Irish communities and fiscal policy making is becoming increasingly remote.
Elements within the Irish government may feel that they are partners with Germany in European recovery, but if the electorate feel differently then the relationship has dubious foundations. I approached several people to speak to me about this issue. I put the question to them, “how do you feel about Germany’s role in the Irish economy?” and nobody felt particularly positive about it. It was certainly difficult to get any clear, unemotional response and most saw Germany and austerity as the same thing. Some resorted to easy clichés and stereotypes, others expressed a reluctant acceptance that decisions were no longer made in Ireland but rather in Berlin.
This is a problem, not a partnership. It is a problem for the legitimacy of our government and for the legitimacy of the whole European project.
The Irish government has a difficult task on its hands: it needs to restore faith, not by patronising citizens but by engaging us, not by ignoring critics but by convincing us that our interests take precedence over those of faceless bondholders and multi-national corporations. Perception, as the old management mantra goes, is nine-tenths of reality, and the perception of the Irish people is of critical importance. When fiscal decisions are made, or are seen to be made, by external parties outside their control, then people step back from the political system and either the dependent or victimised mindset becomes more entrenched or people will rebel against it. None of these outcomes is good news for Europe in the long term.
See also: The luck of the Irish: Denial, disengagement, disillusion – By Lauren Bari
—
Follow Lauren Bari on
Like us on and follow us on .
Dieser Text ist mir etwas wert
|
|



Alltag im Regierungsviertel